WalmartvsAmazon logoAmazon

Which marketplace is better for sellers?

Last updated: June 2026

Quick Verdict

Amazon is the larger, more mature marketplace with unmatched traffic, FBA fulfillment, and advertising depth, but it is fiercely competitive and crowded. Walmart Marketplace is smaller yet growing fast, with notably lower seller competition and no monthly subscription, making it an attractive second channel. Established sellers should treat Amazon as the core and Walmart as a high-upside expansion.

Quick Fee Calculator

Scoring Breakdown

Audience Size

Walmart7/10
Amazon10/10

Amazon leads US e-commerce with the largest online shopper base and dominant search intent. Walmart Marketplace reaches a large and growing online audience built on Walmartโ€™s retail brand, but its marketplace traffic is still well behind Amazonโ€™s.

Seller Competition

Walmart8/10
Amazon4/10

Walmart Marketplace has far fewer third-party sellers and a more curated onboarding process, so visibility is easier to earn. Amazon is saturated with millions of sellers competing hard on price for the buy box.

Fulfillment

Walmart7/10
Amazon9/10

Amazon FBA is the benchmark, deeply integrated with Prime. Walmart Fulfillment Services (WFS) is capable and improving, offering fast shipping badges, but the network and ecosystem are less extensive than Amazonโ€™s.

Fees & Costs

Walmart8/10
Amazon6/10

Walmart charges no monthly subscription โ€” mainly referral fees per category. Amazon adds a subscription on top of referral and FBA fees. Walmart can be cheaper to maintain, though Amazonโ€™s traffic may justify its costs; verify current rates.

Walmart: Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Lower seller competition and easier visibility
  • No monthly subscription fee
  • Backed by Walmartโ€™s trusted retail brand
  • Growing online audience
  • WFS fulfillment with fast-shipping badges

Cons

  • Smaller marketplace audience than Amazon
  • Selective onboarding can slow approval
  • Less mature seller and ad tooling
  • Strict performance and pricing rules

Amazon logoAmazon: Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Largest online buyer base with high intent
  • FBA fulfillment and Prime eligibility
  • Most mature advertising platform
  • Deep category coverage
  • Strong consumer trust

Cons

  • Extremely competitive buy-box environment
  • Subscription plus referral and FBA fees
  • Strict policies and account-health risk
  • Hard to differentiate and protect margins
  • Price pressure from global sellers

Related Comparisons

Frequently Asked Questions

Sell on both Walmart & Amazon

Marqetir manages your listings across all European marketplaces.

Free 7-day trial โ€ข Cancel anytime